ERP Comparison White Paper: Microsoft Dynamics AX, SAP Business One, & Odoo

Introduction

Introducing ERP offers available today

In the last 15 years, new technologies have pushed enterprises both large and small to rethink their process management with respect to the new dynamics created by the changing business landscape. Implementing an ERP is a step many businesses are taking to help organize and optimize the way they do business.

There are many business software offerings currently available on the market, however, most are focused solely on the needs of large enterprises. This document aims to give you a good idea of the features offered by the main ERP solutions for SME’s, with an emphasis on cloud-based solutions.

A cloud-hosted ERP solution offers a number of advantages over a traditional ERP that is installed locally, many of which are especially relevant to small businesses. A cloud-based ERP is often more flexible and able to adapt to a growing and changing business. Most of the time, startup and maintenance costs are much lower as well because they are included in the license fee.

Feature Comparison

In order to offer a fair comparison, we have compiled a table of the most important features into ten categories: Sales, Customer Relationship Management, Accounting & Finance, Marketing, Warehouse Management, Manufacturing, Purchasing, Services & Projects, Human Resources, and Usability & Productivity.

These categories encompass almost everything an SME might need to manage, develop, and evolve its business operations. The three products analyzed have extra third-party apps, developed by partners. Both NetSuite and Odoo have a public app store. Microsoft Dynamics NAV however has no app store; you will have to contact each partner individually in order to get information about their extra modules. As these modules usually come at an additional cost (license fees and/or implementation service), we only reported features that are in the standard package within our analysis. We have also included a comprehensive list of the pricing conditions to better weigh the costs/benefits for each solution.

We will finalize this document with some observations on market trends and customer satisfaction as well as provide input on a more global solution for SME’s.

Choosing the Right Software

Whether you are outgrowing entry-level software or replacing a legacy system, choosing an ERP that is a good fit for your company can have a strong impact on your future growth and profitability. Because the cost of implementing an ERP is so high, demanding a great deal of time and input from employees across your organization as well as potentially significant software licensing and consulting fees, there is tremendous pressure to get it right the first time.

Despite these high stakes, most decision makers selecting and implementing ERP software will not do so more than a few times in their career. The purchasing relationship is therefore tilted in favor of the vendor, with many vendors requiring hours of qualification before revealing crucial details such as features and pricing. When dealing with vendors, it is, therefore, essential to accurately and completely communicate the needs of your organization to avoid finding out 6 months into an implementation that the project isn’t feasible or that unexpected and expensive custom development is required.

Cloud or On-Premises?

In recent years there has been a trend in business software towards a software as a service (SaaS) model. Most major business software vendors, ERP or otherwise, have begun offering their locally installed products in a cloud-hosted version to provide additional flexibility. When deploying a cloud-based software, there is no need for a local server or other network hardware as data is managed and processed on a secure off-site server which, depending on the size of the deployment, can significantly reduce the initial cost of a system. This can make a cloud solution a better choice for small and medium-size businesses with less capital.

Inventory Management

Features Odoo SAP Business One Microsoft Dynamics AX
General
Multi-Warehouse
Storage Locations(Bins)
Bin Replenishment
Mobile Device Support
Multi-Company
Multi-Currency
Multi-Language
Automatic ASN (Advanced Shipping Notice)
Package Management/Cartoning
Freight Carrier Integration
Manage Consignee Stocks
EDI(Electronic Data Interchange)
Products
Non-Stocked Inventory
Multiple Variants
Multiple Unit of Measure
Inter-Class UoM Conversion*
Variant Matrix
Traceability
Lots/Serials
Up/Down Traceability
360 ° Traceability
Expiration Dates
Cycle Counting
Reporting
Inventory Forecast
Inventory Valuation
ABC Analysis
Barcode Support
QR Code Support
RFID Support
Lots/Serial Number
Receptions
Picking
Internal Moves
Delivery Orders
Inventory Adjustments
Routing
FIFO/LIFO
Customizable Routes
Putaway Strategies
Wave Picking
Batch Picking
Zone Picking
Cluster Picking
Cross – Docking
Putaway Location Size, Weight & Capacity

Supply Chain

Features Odoo SAP Business One Microsoft Dynamics AX
Features
Vendor Data Management
Vendor Pricelist Management
Inbound Quality Control
Drop shipping
Purchases
Purchase Requests
Purchase Orders
Purchase Approval Workflow
Request for Quotations
Contracts/Purchase Agreements
Automated Procurements
Minimum Stock Rules
Make–to–Order
Master Production Schedule

Manufacturing

Features Odoo SAP Business One Microsoft Dynamics AX
Master Data
Multi-Level BoM
ByProducts/CoProducts
Routings
Sub-Assemblies
One BoM for Multiple Product Variants
BoM Versions
Multiple BoM/Planning
Planning
Demand Forecasting
MRP I Scheduler
MRP II Scheduler
Master Production Schedule
Gantt Chart Scheduling with Drag & Drop
Kanban Planning
Production Calendar
Infinite Capacity Planning
Finite Capacity Planning
Available to Promise
Multiple Scheduling Plans
Delivery Date Calculation (Backwards Scheduling)
Production Order Splitting/Merging
Operations
Manufacturing/Production Orders
Job Tracking
Work Orders/Operations
Automated Time Tracking
Disassembly Orders
Subcontract Manufacturing
Rework/Repair
Scrap Management
Disposal Strategies
Kits
Edit Individual Production BoMs
Costing
Perpetual Inventory Valuation
Periodic Inventory Valuation
Standard Price
FIFO
Landed Costs
Actual Production Labor
Production Order Costing
Shop Floor Control
Shop Floor Terminals
Production Activities
Non- Production Activities
Time Tracking
Messages on Work Orders
Barcode Support
Equipment/Machine Management
Work Instructions on Work Orders
Maintenance Requests from Shop Floor Terminal
Human Resources
Schedule Management
Touchscreen Attendance
Timesheets
Breaks
Overtime
Vacation/Injury
Reporting and Forecasting
Overall Equipment Efficiency
Work Time
Demand Forecast
Maintenance KPIs
Production Cost Analysis
Up/Downstream Traceability
Analytic Accounting
CSV Export
Dynamic Pivot Tables
Save Custom Reports

Maintenance

Features Odoo SAP Business One Microsoft Dynamics AX
Scheduling and Request Handling
Schedule Preventive Maintenance
Maintenance Kanban
Maintenance Calendar
Shop Floor Integration
Multiple Teams/Sites
Asset Management
Subcontract Repair
Job Tracking
Parts Management
Inventory Management
Purchasing integration
Rotating Asset Location
Equipment Serial Numbers
Equipment Maintenance History

QMS–Quality Management

Features Odoo SAP Business One Microsoft Dynamics AX
Quality Control
At Reception
In–Process
Before Delivery
Inventory Quarantine
Quality Checks
Quality Control Plan
Pass / Fail Checks
Measurement Checks
Quality Alerts
Print Nonconformance Documents
Corrective Actions
ISO9001 TOOLS
Documentation Management
Customer Satisfaction Survey
Customer Complaints Management
Traceability of Operations
Resources Management
Reports
Nonconformance Costs

PLM – Product Lifecycle Management

Features Odoo SAP Business One Microsoft Dynamics AX
Features
Engineering Change Orders (ECOs)
BoM Version Management
Routing Version Management
MRP Integration
Centralized BoM Management
ECO Management
Approval Workflows
BoM Version Difference Viewer
Bulk BoM Updates
Notification Mechanism
Project email Gateway
ECO Costing
Third Party CAD Integrations
AutoCAD
Solid Works
Autodesk
Cut List

User Interface

user interface

Usability, especially in enterprise software, is an often- overlooked but critically important aspect to consider during the purchasing process. Usability affects the efficiency of users working within the system, the ease with which the software can be implemented, and can reduce the costs associated with user errors.

Additionally, users who spend most of their working day using the system will appreciate software that is easy to use. This is especially true for shop floor control systems, as workers there may be in a loud environment, moving quickly, wearing PPE, or otherwise not optimally situated to use a traditional computer interface with a keyboard and mouse. The special design considerations of shop space or production line must be taken into consideration for any interface used there.

We have selected screenshots of analogous menus within each software to demonstrate the visual elements and interface options for each software in this comparison. While it is difficult to assess software usability with a static image, a rough comparison can be made. The additional information can only aid your analysis.

User Interface – SAP Business One

sap BOM
SAP Business One -BOM
Sap Master data
SAP Business One – Product Master data

User Interface – Odoo

Odoo BOM
Odoo -BOM
OdooMasterdata
Odoo Production scheduling

Usability & Productivity

Features Odoo SAP Business One Microsoft Dynamics AX
UI
Full Web Interface
Responsive Mobile UI
Android Native App
iOS Native App
Market Place
Full Web Interface
Odoo SAP Business One Microsoft Dynamics AX
Subjective Ratings
Ease of Use












Navigation and Search












Data Entry












Mobile App












Reports Flexibility












Pricing & Conditions

Features Odoo SAP Business One Microsoft Dynamics AX
PRICING $25/User/Month $2,975/User Perpetual + 18% Per Year + AMC Charges $2,000 – $6,000/User
Contract Duration Monthly / Annual Annual Perpetual
Five Year Cost, 50 Users $75,000 $282,625 $100,000
$300,000
Free Trial
New Version Upgrades Included
Update Service Included
Cloud Offer Available

Conclusion

Many factors must be considered when choosing a manufacturing software. The complexity of the production workflow, the degree to which demand fluctuates, the lead times of production and procurement, the size of the organization, the growth rate of the business, the stock keeping needs, the complexity of the support operations in a plant. The list, as they say, goes on. You must make the decision based on your own superlative knowledge of your business while working closely with whichever vendor you choose.

“Above all, choosing the right ERP partner is Vital”

We did our best to make it objective and fair. If you find a mistake or a missing feature, please report it to info@Prixgen.com and we will update this document. Our goal is to have a continuously updated comparison of the main competitors to be as accurate as possible

Source:odoo

Are you ready to take your business to the next level?

We’re always ready to help!

This will close in 0 seconds